Review: After Seeing Neil Diamond’s A Beautiful Noise, I’m a believer

  • A new musical on the life of Neil Diamond has opened at Sydney’s Lyric Theatre
  • Of course, it features the songwriter’s most famous hits.
  • But it also reveals his life story in a vivid and gloriously energetic musical show.

A musical about an ageing Neil Diamond seeking medical help because his family thinks he’s impossible to live with didn’t sound too promising on paper. But after seeing A Beautiful Noise at the Lyric Theatre, I completely changed my mind. It’s two hours of constant revelation about a prolific songwriter and performer I now realise I hardly knew.

Diamond started out as a down-at-heel songwriter from Brooklyn. Among his early successes was ‘I’m a Believer’, which he wrote for the Monkees. He hated doing it.

There’s a lovely irony in the title of that song. Here was a shy, introverted young man who had a hard time believing in himself and a desperate need to get out on stage and make other people believe in him. He went on to fill arenas and sell tens of millions of records.

Australia took to him with particular enthusiasm. Hot August Night, his 1972 live album, spent 29 weeks at number one here. That gives you some idea of how well an Australian audience knows this material.

‘Sweet Caroline’ is an anthem, of course, but my favourite is still ‘You Don’t Bring Me Flowers’. There’s something truly emotional about a song that measures the end of a love affair in such an ordinary gesture.

Neil Diamond's A Beautiful Noise

What made this show particularly appealing for me was the backstory.

The older Diamond shuffles into his doctor’s consulting room, looking angry enough to make you wonder how he could possibly have written songs that have given so many people such pleasure.

His doctor, played by Monica Sayers, takes him through his songbook. She keeps asking him to look at the words. And there, in songs we’ve all been singing for decades, is a loneliness that’s easy to miss when the music is carrying you along.

Will Swenson is brilliant as the younger Diamond. He has the full head of hair, the wonderful throaty voice and just enough awkwardness to make you believe the fellow who can hold an arena in the palm of his hand would be ill at ease in a room with a few strangers. That’s what makes his performance so strong. You can see the shy man in the showman.

Terence Crawford gives an equally commanding performance as the older Diamond. You can feel his anger at having to give up the thing he’d spent his life learning to do. In 2018, Diamond announced he had Parkinson’s disease and retired from touring, cancelling dates in Australia and New Zealand.

By then he’d spent half a century taking his music to audiences around the world. The show also takes us through the strains on his private life, including the toll that a career on the road can take on a marriage. Diamond has been married three times. By the time we’re back in the consulting room, that grumpiness seems entirely understandable.

And a shout-out to one of the most energetic casts I’ve seen on stage in a long time. The dancers and, God bless, the live orchestra can take you from the doctor’s consulting room to a concert hall in the space of a song. That swing between the two is what makes the evening work. You get the pleasure of hearing ‘Cracklin’ Rosie’ and ‘Forever in Blue Jeans’ at full tilt, then find yourself back with a man who has to work out what to do with his life when the applause stops.

I went in thinking I knew Neil Diamond because of his familiar songs. I came out wanting to listen to them again, this time with a closer ear for the words.

Diamond may have become a Solitary Man, but he’s still A Beautiful Noise.

Neil Diamond's A Beautiful Noise

A Beautiful Noise at a glance

WhatA Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
WhereSydney Lyric Theatre, 55 Pirrama Road, Pyrmont
WhenNow playing until Sunday 14 February 2027
Running timeApproximately 2 hours 30 minutes, including a 20-minute interval
TicketsFrom $69. Transaction fees apply.
BookingsTicketmaster or call 02 9509 3600

Peter Lynch

Publisher


About Me

Related Posts